Annotation:Planxty Davis: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| (One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
{{TuneAnnotation | {{TuneAnnotation | ||
|f_tune_annotation_title= https://tunearch.org/wiki/Annotation:Planxty_Davis > | |f_tune_annotation_title= https://tunearch.org/wiki/Annotation:Planxty_Davis > | ||
|f_annotation='''PLANXTY DAVIS''' ("Pleraca Daibis" or "Plearaca Daiti"). AKA and see "[[ Killicrankie (2)]]," "[[Battle of Kilicrankie]]." Irish, Hornpipe or Long Dance (2/4 time). D Major. Standard tuning (fiddle). AB (O'Neill/Krassen): AABB (O'Neill/1001). "Planxty Davis" is one of the supposed seven or eight hundred compositions of the ancient harper [[biography:Thomas O'Connellan|Thomas O'Connellan]]<ref>Dates of birth are variously given as 1620, 1625 and 1640, and death as 1685, 1689, 1698 and 1700. Details of his life are similarly contradictory and vague. </ref>, almost all of which are lost. The melody is occasionally attributed to Turlough O'Carolan, but | |f_annotation='''PLANXTY DAVIS''' ("Pleraca Daibis" or "Plearaca Daiti"). AKA and see "[[ Killicrankie (2)]]," "[[Battle of Kilicrankie]]." Irish, Hornpipe or Long Dance (2/4 time). D Major. Standard tuning (fiddle). AB (O'Neill/Krassen): AABB (O'Neill/1001). "Planxty Davis" is listed as one of the supposed seven or eight hundred compositions of the ancient harper [[biography:Thomas O'Connellan|Thomas O'Connellan]]<ref>Dates of birth are variously given as 1620, 1625 and 1640, and death as 1685, 1689, 1698 and 1700. Details of his life are similarly contradictory and vague. </ref>, almost all of which are lost. Whether O'Connellan was the composer is possible, but unverifiable, and no factual support has surfaced to bolster the assertion. The melody is occasionally attributed to Turlough O'Carolan, but it is highly unlikely that O'Carolan was mature and skilled enough to have composed it, based on the dates of the tune's appearance in Scotland as “[[Battle of Kilicrankie]]/[[Killicrankie (2)]].” The "Killiecrankie" title was used in Scots and English publications some 100 years before it appears in an Irish volume as "Planxty Davis," and Keith Sanger suggests the Irish title could be a mistake, transferred from O'Carolan's "[[Two William Davises]]." | ||
<br> | |||
<br> | |||
See also note for “[[annotation:Breach of Aughrim (The)]]” for more on O'Connellan. | |||
|f_source_for_notated_version= | |f_source_for_notated_version= | ||
|f_printed_sources=O'Neill (Krassen), 1976; p. 165. O'Neill ('''Music of Ireland: 1850 Melodies'''), 1903; No. 1561, p. 289. O'Neill ('''Dance Music of Ireland: 1001 Gems'''), 1907; No. 973, p. 167. | |f_printed_sources=O'Neill (Krassen), 1976; p. 165. O'Neill ('''Music of Ireland: 1850 Melodies'''), 1903; No. 1561, p. 289. O'Neill ('''Dance Music of Ireland: 1001 Gems'''), 1907; No. 973, p. 167. | ||
Latest revision as of 01:52, 4 February 2024
X:1 T:Planxty Davis C:Thomas O'Connelan B:O'Neill's "Dance Music of Ireland", no. 973 Z:Paul de Grae M:4/4 L:1/8 Q:145 K:D FG|A2 AB A2 FG|AFAB A3 B|AGFE DEFG|A2 AB A2 dc| B2 Bd B2 Ac|BABc B2 dB|AGFE DEFA|B2 Bd B2 b2| bafb afeg|fedf e2 de|fedB BAdF|A2 AB A2 dc| B2 AB d2 Bd|e2 de f2 ed|BABc d2 F2|E4 D2:|:fg| a2 ab a2 fg|agab a2 fg|agfe defg|a2 ab a2 fa| b3 b b2 fa|bafa b2 bg|agfe defa|b2 ba b2 fa| bafb afeg|fedf e2 de|fedB BAdF|A2 AB A2 dc| B2 AB d2 cd|e2 de f2 ed|BABc d2 F2|E4 D2:|
PLANXTY DAVIS ("Pleraca Daibis" or "Plearaca Daiti"). AKA and see "Killicrankie (2)," "Battle of Kilicrankie." Irish, Hornpipe or Long Dance (2/4 time). D Major. Standard tuning (fiddle). AB (O'Neill/Krassen): AABB (O'Neill/1001). "Planxty Davis" is listed as one of the supposed seven or eight hundred compositions of the ancient harper Thomas O'Connellan[1], almost all of which are lost. Whether O'Connellan was the composer is possible, but unverifiable, and no factual support has surfaced to bolster the assertion. The melody is occasionally attributed to Turlough O'Carolan, but it is highly unlikely that O'Carolan was mature and skilled enough to have composed it, based on the dates of the tune's appearance in Scotland as “Battle of Kilicrankie/Killicrankie (2).” The "Killiecrankie" title was used in Scots and English publications some 100 years before it appears in an Irish volume as "Planxty Davis," and Keith Sanger suggests the Irish title could be a mistake, transferred from O'Carolan's "Two William Davises."
See also note for “annotation:Breach of Aughrim (The)” for more on O'Connellan.
- ↑ Dates of birth are variously given as 1620, 1625 and 1640, and death as 1685, 1689, 1698 and 1700. Details of his life are similarly contradictory and vague.