Annotation:Dowd's Favorite (1): Difference between revisions

Revision as of 08:36, 1 April 2012

DOWD'S FAVORITE. AKA - "Dowd's Reel," "O'Dowd's Favourite." Irish, Reel. G Aeolian (Gm) ('A' and 'C' parts) & B Flat Major ('B' part) [Brody, Vallely]. Standard tuning (fiddle). AABBCC (Brody): ABC (Miller & Perron, Vallely): ABCD (Miller & Perron/2006). The melody is a setting of the Scottish march/strathspey "The Braes of Bushbie," perhaps composed by John Bowie and appearing in his 1789 Collection. It was said to be a favorite of the great Scots fiddler Niel Gow's. Reworked as "O'Dowd's Favourite" (often called "Dowd's Favorite") it was famously recorded by County Sligo/New York fiddler Michael Coleman (1891-1945) in 1921. Coleman himself probably obtained the melody from Sligo fiddler John O'Dowd (uncle of Joe O'Dowd {1913-1987}), who also had emigrated to New York and where Coleman heard him play. See also the related tunes "The Rover [4]," "Dublin Lasses," "Murtough Mulloy" and "Tee Ree Reel;" they have a similar sequence in the first part. "The Curragh Races" and "The Maid in the Cherry Tree" are also related, and like "Dowd's Favorite," shift to the relative major in the second part. Interestingly, for a tune with Scottish origins adapted by Irish musicians as a reel, it has returned to a mostly-Scottish tradition on Cape Breton, where it has entered the repertoire through the playing of fiddlers such as Johnny Wilmot (1916-1993) who was thoroughly versed in both Cape Breton Scottish and Irish music styles. Randy Miller (2006) added a 4th part, "based on the original strathspey," to the usual 3-part version.

Source for notated version: Steeleye Span (England) [Brody]; fiddler Andy McGann (1928-2004, New York City) [Miller & Perron]; Hughie Gillespie [Bulmer & Sharpley].

Printed sources: Brody (Fiddler's Fakebook), 1983; p. 89. Bulmer & Sharpley (Music from Ireland), 1974, vol. 2, No. 5. Miller & Perron (Irish Traditional Fiddle Music), 1977; vol. 1, No. 22. Miller & Perron (Irish Traditional Fiddle Music), 2nd Edition, 2006; p. 64. Vallely (Play 50 Reels with Armagh Pipers Club), 1982; No. 15, p. 9 (appears as "Dowd's Reel").

Recorded sources: Chrysalis 0698, Steeleye Span - "Ten Man Mop or Mr. Reservour Butler Rides Again" (1976). Columbia CAL504-1, Paddy O'Brien (195?). Folkways FW 8821, Paddy O'Brien - "Irish Dance Music" (1973). Green Linnet GLCD 3105, Aly Bain - "Lonely Bird" (1996. Appears as "Dowd's Reel," learned from Sean Maguire). Gael-Linn, "Michael Coleman 1895-1941." Green Linnet SIF 3006C, Hugh Gillespie - "Classic Recordings of Irish Traditional Music" (1992). Green Linnet GLCD 3127, Sharon Shannon - "The Best of Sharon Shannon: Spellbound" (1999. Learned from Mirella Murrey, Clifden, Co. Galway). Pegasus Mooncrest 9, Steeleye Span- "Ten Man Mop." Philo 200l, "Jean Carignan" (appears as the third tune of 'Cape Breton Medley'. Carignan learned his version from the Andy McGann recording). Rounder CD 11661-7033-2, Natalie MacMaster - "My Roots Are Showing" (2000). Shanachie 29002, "Kathleen Collins." Shaskeen Records OS-360, Andy McGann - "A Tribute to Michael Coleman" (c. 1965). Topic TSCD602, Michael Coleman (et al) - "Irish Dance Music" (1973. Originally recorded 1921). Viva W103, Sean McGuire - "Irish Jigs and Reels" (c. 1960's, a reissue of "Sean Maguire Plays," the first recording of McGuire that Josephine Keegan accompanied on piano). Natalie McMaster - "My Roots are Showing" (1998). Buddy MacMaster - "The Judique Flyer."

See also listings at:
Alan Snyder's Cape Breton Fiddle Recording Index [1]
Jane Keefer's Folk Music Index: An Index to Recorded Sources [2]
Alan Ng's Irishtune.info [3]

Tune properties and standard notation