Annotation:Sally Goodin

---

X:1 T:Sally Goodin’ M:2/4 L:1/8 R:Air B:E.F. Adam - Old Time Fiddlers Favorite Barn Dance Tunes (1928, No. B:50, p. 20 Z:AK/Fiddler's Companion K:A A/c/B/A/ [AA](A/B/)|c/A/B/A/ [F/A/]-[A/A/][AA]|A/c/B/A/ [AA](A/F/)|E/C/E/E/ [F/A/]-[A/A/][AA]:| |:[c/e/]-[ee]([c/e/] [ee])c/e/|(f/g/)a/e/ (f/e/)c/d/|ef/e/ (c/B/)A/B/|c/A/B/A/ [F/A/]-[A/A/][AA]:|

---

SALLY GOODIN'. AKA – “Sally Gooden,” "Sally Goodwin." Old-Time; Texas Style; Breakdown. USA; Widely known. A Major (most versions): G Major (John Brown, Phillips/Davenport). AEae (Eck Robertson) or Standard tunings (fiddle). AB (Bayard): AAB (Phillips/Martin): AABB (Brody, Kartchner, Phillips, Thede): AABB' (Phillips/Davenport): AABB’CBB’ (Beisswenger & McCann): AABBCCDD (Sweet): AA'BB'CDCD (Ford): AABBCCDDEE (Phillips/Franklin): AABB'CC'DDEE (Frets). USA, A widely known breakdown and play-party tune/song in parts of the upland South, Mid-West and Southwest (but not universally known throughout the country--Paul Gifford reports that it was completely unknown to traditional fiddlers in Michigan, for example). As is often the case with American fiddle tunes, there is a wide variety of versions and variants, plus idiosyncratic renderings) in both the key of 'A' and 'G'. Penn State collector and musicologist Samuel Bayard (1981) was of the opinion that the tunes "Sally Goodin," "Old Dan Tucker" and his Pennsylvania collected "Rye Whiskey (2)" (a breakdown, not the 3/4 time version) are related "in an affinity that goes back a long while;" and some versions of these tunes do seem to blend with one another.

Charles Wolfe (1982) states it was popular with Kentucky fiddlers. According to A.B. Moore in his History of Alabama (1934), “Sally Goodin” was one of the standard tunes in an (Alabama) fiddler’s repertoire. Rosenbaum (1989) remarks that it is an almost universally known fiddle tune in the South, but that the verses (an example is given below) are not sung 'as frequently today' as they were in the past. Texas fiddler Eck Robertson was the first person to record the tune in 1922 when he was aged thirty-four (Robertson, is was recalled, played the tune at variously in both AEae and standard tuning, although on his early and famous recording he played in AEae). Robertson was by accounts a colorful personality, who used to introduce the tune in performance something akin to the following (wrote fiddler Byron Berline, Frets Magazine):

There was a girl named Sally who had two boyfriends. The two boys were both fiddle players, and one of the boys had the last name of 'Goodin.' Sally couldn't decide which one to marry, so she thought a fiddle contest between the two would be a good way to make her selection. Of course, the fellow Goodin won the contest, and Sally became Sally Goodin. They were very happy and had a productive life with 14 children, so I'm going to play 'Sally Goodin' 14 different ways.

Arizona fiddler Kenner C. Kartchner said: "Old Texas tune. Only a few play it well. All try it" (Shumway), and indeed, it is played today by Texas-style fiddlers, usually with multiple variation parts. In other regions of the country two-part versions prevail. Missouri fiddler Bob Holt (1930-2004) played the tune in three parts, but acknowledged that most fiddlers in the Ozarks region played it in two. Bruce Green believes the tune was originally called “Boatin’ Up Sandy” (there are several tunes by this name) and was renamed during the American Civil War by Confederate soldiers attached to John Hunt Morgan’s unit of irregulars. The story, as Green tells it, is that the company arrived at a point on the Big Sandy River in Pike County, Kentucky. A boarding house run by Sally Goodin was located nearby where she allowed the soldiers to camp and to play music. In appreciation of her hospitality the soldiers renamed the tune in her honor (Mike Yates, 2002).

Guthrie Meade (Country Music Sources) lists twenty-nine early 78 RPM recordings, attesting to the popularity and wide dissemination of the reel. “Sally Goodin” was in the repertoires of Fiddlin John Carson (North Ga.) {1922}, Fiddlin' Cowan Powers 1877-1952? (Russell County, S.W. Va.) {and who recorded the tune for Victor in August, 1924, though it was unissued}, Uncle Am Stuart (b. 1856, Morristown, Tenn.) {and who re-recorded it for Vocalion in 1924}, Uncle Jimmy Thompson 1848-1931 (Tenn.) {as "Sally Goodwin"}, and Alabama fiddler Monkey Brown (1897-1972). North Georgia fiddler Earl Johnson, with his band the Clodhoppers, recorded a version of the tune in 1928 under the odious title “N....r in the Cotton Patch.” Also in repertoire of legendary fiddler J. Dedrick Harris, born in Tennessee, and who played regularly with Bob Taylor while he was running for Governor of the state in the late 1800's. Harris moved to Western N.C. in the 1920's and influenced a generation of fiddlers there: Osey Helton, Manco Sneed, Bill Hensley, Marcus Martin. The title was mentioned in reports of the De Kalb County Annual (Fiddlers') Convention, 1926-31 (Cauthen, 1990). At the turn of the century it was played by George Cole of Etowah County, Alabama, as recorded by Mattie Cole Stanfield in her book Sourwood Tonic and Sassafras Tea (1965). The tune was recorded for the Library of Congress by musicologist/folklorist Vance Randolph from Ozarks Mountains fiddlers in the early 1940's; he said it was popular at play-parties in the Ozarks in the 1890's (see his Ozark Folksongs, vol. 3). Similarly, it was recorded in 1939 for the Library of Congress by Herbert Halpert from the playing of Itawamba/Tishomingo County, Mississippi, fiddler John Brown and, in the same year from Franklin County, Virginia, fiddler J.W. 'Peg' Hatcher (2741-B-2). Texas fiddler Eck Robertson's 1923 release of "Sally Goodin'" (backed with Robertson and H.C. Gilliland performing “The Arkansas Traveler") was the number one country music bestseller for the year 1923 (although it had been released in a limited pressing in 1922, then more fully the next year). Georgia fiddler Bill Shores, a native Alabamian who spent most of his life in the Rome, Georgia, area (according to Wayne Daniels), recorded the tune (under the title “Sally Goodwin”) with guitarist Riley Puckett in Atlanta in 1926. North Georgia stalwarts The Skillet Lickers waxed “Sally Goodin” in 1929, as did Tennessee entertainer Uncle Dave Macon in 1925. Georgia fiddler A.A Gray played the tune on “A Fiddler’s Tryout in Georgia,” a sham fiddling-contest skit with supposed judges and two fiddlers vying for a prize (Joe Brown was his nemesis)—Gray plays “Bucking Mule” and “Sally Goodin’” on the 78 RPM record. George Edgin recorded it in 1932 under the title “Blue Mountain Sally Goodin.”

Texas fiddler Eck Robertson sang these verses:

Had a piece of pie, had a piece of puddin',
Give it all away to see Sally Goodin'.

I love pie, I love puddin',
Crazy 'bout the gal they call Sally Goodin'.

Looked up the road, seen Sally comin',
Thought to my soul she'd break her neck a-runnin'. ......(Thede)

Had five dollars, now I've got none,
Give it all away to see Sally Goodin.
Hey, ho, old Sally Goodin,
Hey, ho, old Sally Goodin.

Raspberry pie, blackberry puddin',
Give it all away to kiss Sally Goodin.
Hey, ho, old Sally Goodin,
Hey, ho, old Sally Goodin. ......(Rosenbaum/Knight)

Texas swing fiddler Bob Wills' version, with singer Tommy Duncan, goes (from the “Tiffany Transcriptions,” vol. 6):

Sheep and a goat was walkin’ in the pasture,
The sheep said to goat, “Can’t you get a little faster?”
The sheep fell down and the goat rolled over,
Sheep got up with a mouth full of clover

Chorus:
Like my pie, like my puddin',
Love that gal that they call Sally Goodin'

The meat on the goose and the marrow on the bone,
The devil on the hillside don’t you hear him groan;
Turkey playin' fiddle up on the melon vine,
The goose chewin' tobacco while the duck drinkin' wine.

Chorus

Possum up a gum stump, dogs on the ground,
Man [Men] with [a] shotgun[s] walkin' all around;
Boss has stuck his head out, and grinned kinda silly,
Women and children are hollerin' “Willy, Willy.”

Chorus

Grab your gal, turn around and around,
Let your little foot beat against the ground;
Circle eight, spread out wide,
Grab your partner an’ go hogwild.

Musicologist Vance Randolph (Ozark Folksongs) prints sung verses collected from Carrie Barber of Pineville, Missouri, that go:

I had a piece of pie, and I had a piece of pudding;
I gave it all away, to see Sally Goodin.
Swing Sally Goodin, Swing Grandma,
Everybody rag to please grandpa.